#20: Weaknesses of the narrations endorsing the dead recognizing, greeting & replying
Table of Contents
1) From Abu Huraira
2) From another chain via Muhammad ibn Qudamah al-Jawhari
3) Another chain from Yahya ibnul-`Ala’
4) From mother of believers `Aisha radhiallahu `anha – May allah curse those who revile her
4.1) Another narration from mother of the believers `Aisha
4.2) Another route from Aisha
5) From Ibn `Abbas (Radhiallahu `anhu)
6) From Ibn `Umar (radhiallahu `anhu)
7) From Abu Razeen/Abu huraira radhiallahu `anhu
8) The narration of deceased feeling sad upon seeing his beloved from this world
9) From `Abdullah ibn Abu Farwah Madani , Abu Huraira and Ibn `Umar regarding martyrs of Uhud
9.1) Another variant in Mustadrak comes with the wording
10) The incident of marytrs of Uhud speaking to the khala of `Attaf ibn Khalid
10.1) The above report has also come in the following way:
11) From Hashim ibn Muhammad `Umri
12) From Muhammad ibn Waasi`
13) From Abu Sa`eed al-Khudri (radhiallahu `anhu)
14) From Ibn `Abbas regarding the deceased speaking to its carriers
15) From Hibban ibn abu Jabla
16) From `Aasim al-Jahdari
17) From Imam e Azaam Sufyan ath-thawri (D. 161 A.H)
17.1) Another report from Imam e Azam sufyan ath-thawri
18) From Mujahid (D. 104 A.H)
19) Bakr ibn `Abdullah ibn `Amr Muzni (D. 106 A.H)
20) `Amro ibn deenar (D. 126 A.H)
21) Abdur rahman ibn abu layla (D. 83 A.H)
22) Ibn abi Najih (D. 131 A.H)
23) Abu `Abdullah Bakr, al-Muzni
24) Imam sa`eed ibn Mussayab (D. After 90 A.H)
25) From `Ali radhiallahu `anhu regarding Abu Bakr
26) Sahl ibn sa`d (radhiallahu `anhu)
27) `Amr ibn deenar (Rahimahullah
Conclusion
Download : https://www.mediafire.com/?i2absz205bna2tq